Ways to Criticize Software With Your Team

How to Be Constructively Critical of Software: A Guide for All Team Members

Whether you're a product manager, designer, marketer, or anyone else working alongside software developers, providing feedback about software can feel intimidating. However, your perspective as a user and team member is invaluable for creating better products.

Why Your Perspective Matters

As someone who uses software from a business or user perspective, you bring crucial insights:

Real-world usage patterns: You understand how software fits into actual workflows

User empathy: You can identify pain points that technical teams might overlook

Business context: You know how software issues impact customers, sales, or operations

Fresh eyes: You notice problems developers might miss after working on code for weeks

The Golden Rule: Focus on Impact, Not Implementation

The most important principle is to focus on the impact of issues rather than trying to diagnose technical causes or propose solutions.

Instead of: "The database query is probably too slow"

Try: "When I search for customers, it takes 15 seconds to get results, which makes it hard to help customers during phone calls"

Instead of: "You should use a different framework"

Try: "The checkout process requires six different pages, and we're seeing customers abandon their carts at step 4"

Structure Your Feedback Effectively

Use this simple framework:

1. Context

What were you trying to accomplish and under what conditions?

2. Expectation vs. Reality

What you expected to happen versus what actually happened.

3. Impact

How this affects real work, users, or business goals.

4. Frequency

How often you've noticed this issue.

Example: "I was generating the monthly sales report for tomorrow's client meeting (context). I expected a PDF within seconds, but got a loading spinner for 3 minutes before an error (expectation vs. reality). This means I can't prepare for the meeting, and customers might think our platform is unreliable (impact). This is the third time this week (frequency)."

Describe Issues Clearly

Be Specific

Vague: "The app is slow"

Specific: "Loading our customer list takes 30-45 seconds when I first open the app each morning"

Quantify When Possible

"Page loads 10-15 customers at a time, but I need to scroll through 200+ to find who I'm looking for"

"I have to refresh 3-4 times before new orders appear"

Document Steps to Reproduce

"Log in as manager-level user"
"Navigate to Reports > Monthly Summary"
"Select date range: January 1-31, 2024"
"Click 'Generate Report'"
"Error appears after 3 minutes"

⏰ Timing and Communication

Choose the Right Moment

For urgent issues: Direct communication to relevant developer

For general improvements: Team meetings or project management tools

For complex feedback: Written summaries that developers can reference

Make Feedback Actionable

Provide business context and success criteria:

"This checkout problem could be costing sales. Customers have told support they gave up because it was too complicated"

"Ideally, customers could complete checkout in under two minutes"

"I'd be happy to test any changes with real customer scenarios"

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Don't Propose Technical Solutions

Avoid: "You should cache the data in Redis"

Better: "Users wait for the same information to load every time they visit this page, even if they were just here five minutes ago"

Don't Assume Bad Intent

Avoid: "Whoever built this obviously didn't think about usability"

Better: "I think there might be an opportunity to improve the user experience here"

Don't Overwhelm with Minor Issues

Prioritize your feedback. Leading with dozens of small issues can overshadow important functional problems.

Sample Feedback Template

What I was trying to do: [Brief task description]

What I expected: [Expected behavior]

What actually happened: [Actual behavior]

Impact: [Effect on work/users/business]

Frequency: [How often this occurs]

Environment: [Browser, device, etc.]

Handling Difficult Conversations

When Feedback Seems Ignored

Ask about the timeline: "When might this be prioritized?"

Understand constraints: "Are there technical limitations I should know about?"

Explore workarounds: "Is there a temporary solution while we plan a fix?"

When Developers Push Back

Listen to their perspective. There may be constraints you weren't aware of

Focus on the underlying business problem you're trying to solve

Collaborate on alternatives: "If that's too complex, what other options might achieve the same goal?"

Building Collaborative Relationships

Learn Basic Concepts

Understanding frontend vs. backend, browsers vs. devices, and development vs. production environments helps communication.

Establish Regular Rhythms

Weekly check-ins about any pressing issues

Monthly deep dives on user experience

Celebrate improvements when developers address your feedback

-
Antonio Johnson

Join newsletter